[ID] anon@useast.battle.net

[evilmad666]

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 802200.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] Island Defense #59
Your Warcraft III Username: N/A
Violator's Warcraft III Username: anon@useast.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): Leaving as titan without warning before the 20:00 GP mark during game.
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): around 20:45 of GP
Any further thoughts:

Left without warning, clear chance of still winning. And less than 3 that were not minions/died left the game.

[F-Train]

No, Titan may leave after 10 minutes of game (time must be noted from when titan spawns (GP timer starts))

[evilmad666]

No, Titan may leave after 10 minutes of game (time must be noted from when titan spawns (GP timer starts))

Wrong. It is 20:00 of GP.
According to this:

STORAGE ENT CHAT:
(15:51:06) evilmad666: For leaving as titan during an ID game. Is it bannable if they leave BEFORE the 10 minute gold pen. mark? or 10minute in-game timer?
(15:51:28) Cambrioleuse: if they leave before gp says 20:00.
technically it doesn't apply if game is obviously over
(15:51:43) Cambrioleuse: or if 3 people (who were not minis / died) left or were observers
(15:51:49) Cambrioleuse: so if 3 people don't pick titan is fere to leave


Game wasn't over.

[F-Train]

No, Titan may leave after 10 minutes of game (time must be noted from when titan spawns (GP timer starts))

Wrong. It is 20:00 of GP.
According to this:

STORAGE ENT CHAT:
(15:51:06) evilmad666: For leaving as titan during an ID game. Is it bannable if they leave BEFORE the 10 minute gold pen. mark? or 10minute in-game timer?
(15:51:28) Cambrioleuse: if they leave before gp says 20:00.
technically it doesn't apply if game is obviously over
(15:51:43) Cambrioleuse: or if 3 people (who were not minis / died) left or were observers
(15:51:49) Cambrioleuse: so if 3 people don't pick titan is fere to leave


Game wasn't over.

I quoted from wiki tho..

[evilmad666]

No, Titan may leave after 10 minutes of game (time must be noted from when titan spawns (GP timer starts))

Wrong. It is 20:00 of GP.
According to this:

STORAGE ENT CHAT:
(15:51:06) evilmad666: For leaving as titan during an ID game. Is it bannable if they leave BEFORE the 10 minute gold pen. mark? or 10minute in-game timer?
(15:51:28) Cambrioleuse: if they leave before gp says 20:00.
technically it doesn't apply if game is obviously over
(15:51:43) Cambrioleuse: or if 3 people (who were not minis / died) left or were observers
(15:51:49) Cambrioleuse: so if 3 people don't pick titan is fere to leave


Game wasn't over.

I quoted from wiki tho..

yeah just let a mod decide on this. One mod says this, another mod says another thing. lel. Obviously planned on leaving at the "10:00" minute mark when he titaned. Since he left almost exactly the 10minute mark. Trying to work around the rules, and that's bad enough behavior imo. Reason why I posted this.

[darkwolf]

(10:25 / QUIT) anon: Left
i dont see what the problem is he left 25 seconds after what your allowed to leave

[evilmad666]

(10:25 / QUIT) anon: Left
i dont see what the problem is he left 25 seconds after what your allowed to leave

lel.
(15:51:28) Cambrioleuse: if they leave before gp says 20:00.
technically it doesn't apply if game is obviously over
(15:51:43) Cambrioleuse: or if 3 people (who were not minis / died) left or were observers
(15:51:49) Cambrioleuse: so if 3 people don't pick titan is fere to leave

According to stealer its 20:00 on GP. not gametime.

[F-Train]

@cambrioleuse

[Stealer]

10 minutes after titan spawn is 20:00 on GP.....

GP counts down from 30:00, therefore 10 minutes later is 20:00.

[Haunt]

This argument is ridiculous. Why argue over it, giving the same reasons every time? Futile.

Denied.