[dota] sven feeder

[MutantX1211]

Replay Link: storage.entgaming.net/replay/view_replay.php?file=8192408.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA apem us/ca #96
Your Warcraft III Username: Mutant-X
Violator's Warcraft III Username: Azrael , griffinops
Violated Rule(s): Feeders
Time of Violation (in-game or replay): at min 5-6 sven feed , furion feed entire game
Any further thoughts: sven rushed to tower at min 5-6 and furion feed entire game both deserve ban however sven is not banned yet

i want another moderator to review this besides beerlord

[Hatedmaru]

This brq has been reported before: viewtopic.php?f=24&t=95770

griffinops is already banned (as mentioned in the last brq)

Reviewing for Azrael which is the only violator left (will edit soonish)

After reviewing (Replay timers):

First death occurs at 6 minutes: He dives into the tower, with furion following him since game start - While sven shoulnd't have done this, im almost sure he was doing this to prove the fact furion was a gameruiner and following him 24/7 (since no1 actually believed him)
2nd death occurs at 08:25 when meepo comes ganking him and furion on river (Meepo and furion are the 2 multiboxing/dodgers friends)
3rd death occurs at 12:00 - Hes ganked by zeus and witch doctor, and dies
4th death occurs at 21:00 - Dies in a teamfight, after helping killing witch doctor
5h Death occurs at 26:30 - Dies defending botlane
6th Death occurs at 31:00 - Dies defending toplane
7th death occurs at 32:00 - Creeps inside fountain, doctor came with cask and his ulti and kills him

So overall, no he wasn't feeding purposely, intentionally or by playing reckless - He was trying to win, even with the odds against ur team, got the right items, etc - So nothing bannable from his actions (Yes his 1st death could be considered feeding, but considering the evidence, i woulnd't ban him based on that 1 death, looking at how he played till the end)

PS: Axe without boots, blademail but Sange & Yasha instead - are you joking... ?

[MutantX1211]

You said it yourself he shouldnt have done it so i am allowed to feed couple of deaths if i play till the end?Im aware theres another post thats why i asked for someone else to review it by the way i dont need boots of speed just because everyone buys it doesn't mean i am forced to buy it or its essential to get it for everyone i had more kills than sven and i had a dagger to compensate for boots of speed

[Hatedmaru]

You said it yourself he shouldnt have done it so i am allowed to feed couple of deaths if i play till the end?Im aware theres another post thats why i asked for someone else to review it by the way i dont need boots of speed just because everyone buys it doesn't mean i am forced to buy it or its essential to get it for everyone i had more kills than sven and i had a dagger to compensate for boots of speed

The only real death that could be considered feeding was his 1st one: Simply stated that considering the case, and the fact that was a 1 situation only, he shoulnd't be banned for it.

PS: Regarding your item choice .. Well you can play axe any way you want obviously, but someone who picks s&y over blademail on axe ... definitely the worst choice, without a single doubt here.

[Jabba41]

Processed in another topic.