[DOTA] Coldfire786 US East

[CriticalSeasons]

Game link (if known): http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 195324.w3g
Game name: [ENT] DotA apem us/ca #48
Your Warcraft III username: TheFinerThings
Violator's Warcraft III username: Coldfire786
Rule player violated: Maphack
Time of violation (specify whether you are using in-game or replay time): 12 min-13min
Any further thoughts:
I was running away from a gank from the middle of the map, towards the top lane, where are all the trees are (past the top tower). The player Coldfire786 followed me straight into the woods, what amazed me was him moving exactly the direction I was going through(once I was inside the trees).

[Cat_Fact]

There is almost nothing to indicated MH. The closest thing would be only three incidents of the entire game. Replay clock.

11:38 - Went to cut off troll and kill him. The thing about this is that Slark stopped to wait for little before cutting troll off and killing him. This could be suspicious, but I said no. Many very experiences player have great timing skill. This is what make them pro. He had prior vision, so this is justified.

14:30 - Chasing Pugna. Lost vision at hill chased by creep. Pugna hide in wood by top tower. Slark chase straight to Pugna without vision of him hiding. I would have though he would attempt to cut through the tree line first, just like how he did with troll as stated above. This is questionable, but not entirely suspicious.

16:30 - He call correctly what rune would appear. Even though he stand at the wrong location. This is suspicious regardless of his location.

Two options:

1) He MH and is excellent at hiding it (one of the best) or
2) He is an experiences player and have great timing skill. Quite supported by how he solo mid. As I have also played with him and against him. He have great use of terrain, attack timing, ganking skill, and map awareness among the many.

I have to say no MH.

[CriticalSeasons]

He has great skill, no doubt about that. It's just him chasing me straight into the woods, and moving in the same direction towards me, inside the woods that made me suspicious of him.

[coldfire786]

Hehe let the admits decide but to defend myself I'm gonna say I'm too good so check some replays of meh
And I believe 75% of people go that place to hide

[CriticalSeasons]

Yeah yeah, but your constant verbal attacks never ends. I admit that you are a really high skilled dota player, but as a person... you really get abusive in the games. Seriously man, I've never seen someone rub it in on other people's faces over a 1elo win. Congrats, I guess...

[nabo.]

@CriticalSeasons

So are you accusing of mh or not? Do you retract your request?

[CriticalSeasons]

None of my posts are retracting anything of my very first post. I leave it up you and the rest of the admins to decide whether he is mhing or not.

[ZimmeR]

After reviewing the replay I only see one suspect movement of him (at min 12 ingame timer)
Which isn't enough evidence to ban.

@CriticalSeasons Post more time stamps or this request will be denied.

Also @coldfire786 might explain your thoughts about the action at the 12th min Ingame Timer.

[coldfire786]

Where would u go if u were slark chasing down an lit low hp enemy either next to tower in woods or side shop

[ForMaDawgS]

ight so i'v played over 1000 games with this noob coldie and right now we arn't on good terms but he doesn't mh, if you think he mhs should check more then just one game try his last 15 games coldfire has been a great player in ent dota community for a few years now and deserves more then this.

[ZimmeR]

Denied.