ENT Gaming

Replay Link: http://storage.entgaming.net/replay/vie ... 425220.w3g
Game Name: [ENT] DotA apem us/ca #64
Your Warcraft III Username: olddaysdota
Violator's Warcraft III Username: beerlord@uswest.battle.net, EarthDevour@uswest.battle.net, crackinacan@uswest.battle.net, sweetie@useast.battle.net
Violated Rule(s): AFk, intentional and deliberate feed, refusing to cooperate

(28:01 / Allied) pure_life: !votekick crack
(28:01 / All) EarthDevour: A votekick against player [CRACKinAcan] has been started by player [pure_life]. 6 votes are needed within 60 seconds to pass.
(28:01 / All) EarthDevour: Type !yes to vote.
(28:01 / All) EarthDevour: ** Note: !votekick should only be used to kick players breaking a rule. You should not votekick players new to the game!
(28:05 / Allied) olddaysdota: !yes
(28:05 / All) EarthDevour: Player [olddaysdota] voted to kick player [CRACKinAcan]. 5 more votes are needed to pass.
(28:06 / Allied) blackberry858: !yes
(28:06 / All) EarthDevour: Player [blackberry858] voted to kick player [CRACKinAcan]. 4 more votes are needed to pass.
(28:21 / Allied) BeerLord: -afk
(28:28 / Allied) eMo: !yes
(28:28 / All) EarthDevour: Player [eMo] voted to kick player [CRACKinAcan]. 3 more votes are needed to pass.
(28:33 / All) EarthDevour: Player [olddaysdota]'s forfeit vote has been recalled automatically (three minutes have elapsed).
(28:48) eMo killed dragon3
(29:01 / All) EarthDevour: A votekick against player [CRACKinAcan] has expired.

Players not voting and which should be banned: Beerlord, earthdevour, crackinacan, sweetie.

- EarthDevour: check multi, I think crackinacap is his bot.
- crackinacan: game throwing, afk in base, no team cooperation, feed on purpose on pudge. Possible bot xD.
- Timestamps:
- 04:00 : CRACKinAcan gives first blood to EarthDevour. 2 normal hooks, np.
- 05:42: CRACKinAcan dies to EarthDevour by a hook from tower. np.
- 06:54: CRACKinAcan goes woods leaving mid empty. Doesn't call mia when pudge gangs top.
- 07:00 - 10:00: CRACKinAcan keeps in woods (LEVEL 3)
- 10:00 - 14:00: CRACKinAcan woods, after mediation and yoga he gets level 4.
- 14:00 - 15:00: CRACKinAcan stays in base and tp mid.
- 15:00 - 15:28: CRACKinAcan ( level 4 ) gets hooked by pudge ( level 11 )
- 16:00 - 18:39 CRACKinAcan stays afk in base. After bara told if he was afk, he magically appeared ( level 4 )

b]Time of Violation (in-game or replay)[/b]:
- Beerlord: @28:01-29:01, votekick refusal.
- EarthDevour & crackinacan: Too suspicious

Any further thoughts:

I could keep reviewing but I think the evidence is overhelming. Hope you can review this.
Thanks.

PS: Don't blame Beerlord, I'd loved do take almost 15 elo and a free kd from that situation <3
PS2: In the end of the game even Beerlord stated there was an intentional feed by CRACKinAcan to EarthDevour once again. I think he was not aware of the full picture and that's why he didn't vote.

@olddaysdota beerlord is an admin but when you vote kick it helps to state why.
He did check to see if he was afk but you could have given more information, which is kinda required when vote kicking

Ye, thats why I stated that he was not aware of the whole picture. I thought we was already aware about what was happening. No problem. But please review EarthDevour & crackinacan. I think even Beerlord will agree.

Kind regards and thanks for fhe fast reply.

@beerlord since you were in this game

Well, with respect to the request for bans for failing to votekick veno, I saw nothing in game that was clear evidence for possible game ruining until the very end when veno appeared to intentionally feed at his tower. However the game ended by ff before I could comment on this in chat. My problem with the votekicks were that I could not tell if veno was game ruining or just a new or bad player. Outside of the op, the entire scourge team had essentially the same kd record, so that confused the issue as well. It may well be that veno was game ruining and intentionally feeding, and although that may have been obvious to his allies, it was not so clear to opposing players.

Thank you very much for clarifying Beer. And i was 5-1 till I got kinda angry with the guy ;(, when in chat i typed enough.

7:00 starts jungling
15:00 goes mid and dies
15:30 revive and afk
18:30 end afk
19:20 starts jungling
21:00 starts afk
22:50 ends afk and starts jungling
25:20 tries to fight
27:00 goes jungle
29:15 goes lane and dies instantly
30:30 starts jungle
32:50 dies
34:20 intentional feed

He only intentionally fed once and it was beyond the point where it mattered. The refusal to play, though, is severe (5 minutes AFK and ~18 minutes only in jungle). He didn't play with the team at all. And his item build and jungling methods show he's probably not a noob.

CRACKinAcan@west banned for 5 days - refusal to play