Page 1 of 2

Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 12:37 pm
by HolySchimmel
Just thought it would be nice to have some auto-ending system that ends/draws the game if there are more than 2 leavers one team before 10min. Would be a solution to annoying 3vs5 games that are decided before they ever really started. Would work fine for maps like dota or lod

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 12:57 pm
by Hunter91
10 minutes would be a bit too long. If game not going well early game or random not so good hero, it just need 2 people who leav to end the game as draw? If any, should be after 2min (before 1st creep wave start). And there is a draw command if people want to draw the game.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 2:47 pm
by urogard
Hunter91 wrote:10 minutes would be a bit too long. If game not going well early game or random not so good hero, it just need 2 people who leav to end the game as draw? If any, should be after 2min (before 1st creep wave start). And there is a draw command if people want to draw the game.

no offence but the draw command is bull in these situations
if you use draw, the game doesn't count and the 2 leavers will not get banned (and if it should then there's apparently a bug because I had a game end with a draw yesterday and I checked and the leavers didn't get a ban)

the system should give an instant autoban for 4-6 days to the first person who leaves or dc's
and drawing should still get people banned

if this works then I agree that if within 5 minutes of first creepwave there's 2 leavers (even if on different sides) then game should auto-end and not count as win/loss

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 3:41 pm
by EdgeOfChaos
I support this. If the game timer is under 5:00, and one team has 2+ players than the other team, game auto-draws. This is what the draw command is SUPPOSED to be for, but no one ever uses it, so why not make it autodraw?

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 6:22 pm
by HolySchimmel
I dont think 10 min would be too long. Maybe you could make a difference between -em and non-em games. 5 min for the -em games and 10min for the non-em games should work fine in my experience.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 8:19 pm
by EdgeOfChaos
In ten minutes, you can see that your team is getting smashed. What if a Mort gets 5 kills in the first 10 minutes? I bet many people would leave just to avoid the loss. Maybe even 5 is too long.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 8:38 pm
by Naruto-fr
it should be a draw only if 2 players at least left after less than 3 mins to avoid abuses

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2013 10:35 pm
by EdgeOfChaos
Most of the games that are completely ruined by leavers happen when one person disconnects, then another or two others quit because of 4v5, so I think 3 minutes or even less of a time frame for an autodraw is good. If the game gets ruined after that, they can take their chances with trying to !draw.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2013 12:38 am
by Hunter91
In my opinion would even 3 min to much, because there are heros like Arc or Techi who can easily do an early kill(1st blood) too take a little advantage, and then 2 enemy leav to end the game as draw? The potential for abuse
after 1 minute can be high. And a 3vs5 start dont mean u lose https://entgaming.net/openstats/game/1745988/

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2013 4:31 am
by BurritoCarcass
BGN used to do 2 mins 2+ leavers autodraw. I think it should be 2 minutes and if the game is already missing 2 or more players, the game autodraws. The !draw command is complete bullshit, why would you draw a 5v3 when you are on the team with 5? Its a free win most of the time. Consider this reds, its a good idea and will make a lot of players a lot happier.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2013 10:50 pm
by uakf.b
Maybe working on ENT11 now -- 2 leavers any team in first four minutes.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Sat Jul 27, 2013 1:56 am
by EdgeOfChaos
Thanks Uakf! One more thing, are the leavers autobanned if the game autodraws?

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Sat Jul 27, 2013 2:08 am
by uakf.b
EdgeOfChaos wrote:Thanks Uakf! One more thing, are the leavers autobanned if the game autodraws?

Theoretically.

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Sat Jul 27, 2013 7:30 am
by iCoNNecT
Wait if the game draws is the first two leaver before the draw banned?

Re: Auto ending games with more than 2 leavers on one team

Posted: Sat Jul 27, 2013 7:57 am
by uakf.b
iCoNNecT wrote:Wait if the game draws is the first two leaver before the draw banned?

Read a post up???