Temporarily banned account deleted elo.

[Sofistikos]

Warcraft III username: Logged.
Realm: Europe
Situation: Temporarily banned for pause/unpause
Why you should be unbanned: I typed lms to see the stats of this account and my elo is deleted. Why has this happened? Admin who banned me:Agreements
I would also like to remind again that the reason i got banned (pause/unpause) has nothing to do with my acc. My acc got banned cause of ip assosiation with rule violator:Energized.

[EdgeOfChaos]

Are you Energized?

Deleted stats Deleted stats on logged.@europe.battle.net (legionmega): {1400.76, 52, 39, 13, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0}. agreements 1 Jan 2014 12:43:45 GMT
ELO must have been cleared because you cheated.

[Sofistikos]

So i guess you are not taking into serious consideration my case and you let any irresponsible admin to do whatever his feelings and not his logic tell him to do. Ok guys. Keep up with this good image. I got banned for no reason and not only that i have my elo deleted. I give some months of life to these forums and games.

[EdgeOfChaos]

It's not up to me to "let" agreements do anything. I couldn't restore your stats even if I wanted to. However, if you're innocent in this matter, I am your best friend, as I can help you get your name cleared.

I ask again: are you Energized?

[Sofistikos]

I have played some hours in the same computer that energized played. That's the best i can tell you. It's enough to understand what i am trying to say the last 4 days. I am Logged. Energized is someone who played in the same computer.

[EdgeOfChaos]

You are playing from an internet cafe? or is he your brother or something?

[Sofistikos]

And sthng more. It seems that this guy has sthng personal with me. Cause he banned me some days ago and today he also deleted my elo. This is rly weird. I don't understand why he is doing this. It's seems i am on his target. Do you see any point into that? I don't

[Sofistikos]

No it's not my brother. And i am not in an internet cafe. He is just a friend who played in my pc and do his sh*t with my ip. But ok np ban ip and acc. But why all the account accosiated to that ip. I always play just and fair and i help into this forum community by posting violators. So why should i get banned for someone else's doings. But who cares eventually my elo is deleted and you said you can't do anything. At least remove this innapropriate admin's adminship. it's obvious that this guy can't handle it.


Btw i never said i was playing in an net cafe. I used it as an example for that fail allias command which should be removed from your bots as elo balancer should be put.

[EdgeOfChaos]

How many games did your friend play at your computer? And, how many days was that over, if you can remember.

Also: I can't directly do anything, but if I can prove or disprove what you're saying, others will.

[Sofistikos]

He played many. Don't remember exactly. I think around 10?. I think it was 4-5 days ago when he got banned and me along with him.

I answer fast so you can see i am not thinking so i can make a plot..

[EdgeOfChaos]

Here's all the evidence I've gotten so far:
(IPs)
We'll call the IP that was played with Energizer, his first game on record, to be IP A. (For mods: https://entgaming.net/bans/game.php?id=2610395)
The IP used for both Logged. and Energizer's last game, we'll call IP B. (For mods: https://entgaming.net/bans/game.php?id=2647857)

Until 28 Dec 2013 15:27:14 GMT , or the game [ENT] Legion TD Mega #9, Logged. was using IP A to play. From then on, for about 5 games, he used IP B to play. This is either just a random shift in dynamic IPs, or it is him playing on his friend's computer. First, I checked "Users who have played with IP" and entered IP A into it, then did the same for IP B.
Results (IP A):
sofotatos europe.battle.net 2013-12-24 16:10:47 1 7 Yes
energized europe.battle.net 2013-12-29 18:00:30 4 18 Yes
logged. europe.battle.net 2013-12-28 17:17:00 8 56 Yes
Results (IP B):
logged. europe.battle.net 2013-12-28 17:17:00 8 56 Yes
energized europe.battle.net 2013-12-29 18:00:30 4 18 Yes

What this means is that, at some time, logged. and energized both played with IP A and IP B. In other words, for this to be possible, they would have had to play at each others house at least one time. This is not unlikely.

Next, I'll check the trends of user "logged."'s IP. If, at 28 Dec 2013 15:27:14 GMT (when Energized's IP switched over), Logged.'s IP changed from IP A to IP B, this means that it is most likely the same user. I'll check one game before the specified time, and one game after the specified time.
Results:
Before: https://entgaming.net/bans/game.php?id=2628133 - IP A.
After: https://entgaming.net/bans/game.php?id=2639430 - IP B.
For this to have happened, either he would have had to play at energized's house the game before this happened, then energized played at his house. Or, his IP switched over from IP A to IP B, meaning that it is very likely that they are the same user.

To go against this evidence is that there seems to be some skill gap between the two users: Energized is 10/8 and just above 1k elo, whereas logged. was 1400 elo. But then again, there were only 18 games played on energized, and people do have losing streaks.

It looks likely to me that it is the same user. Anyone else want to comment/add new evidence?

[eldryan]

Skill difference might be significant. I'll watch the games and check playstyles - obviously can be faked, but unlikely if he didn't expect ban, and would have certain differences.

[EdgeOfChaos]

Seems strange to me that after I posted that, he stopped responding.