[Battleship]ehf @ useast

[lolships]

Your Warcraft III username: asia.beast
Violator's Warcraft III username: ehf
Game name or map name: [ent] Battleships Pro 5v5 #35
Stats page link: https://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=2994747
Rule player violated: Intentional feeding, repeated dropping of hulls in enemy
Time of incidents (Note in-game timer or replay timer): By 15:00 in-game until 25:00 in-game (possibly later as well)
Any further thoughts: His reasoning for doing so was apparently that I had pooled myself on my team. I have been unable to find anything in the rules that suggests pooling one's self is frowned upon. It is does change the dynamic of the game, but is weak in that it lessens the support offered to the pooled boat, and is of course counterable with a replicator (a 2v1 should see the team of 2 winning every time with competent players).

[mild7777seven]

I was in the game. And honestly, I agree what ehf did. I suggest admin not ban ehf for what he did.

The reason ehf feed all game is, the game was already ruined by asia.beast.

If u check the reply, u will see asia.beast and his other 2 accounts joined the game together. During the game, those 2 accounts did nothing but pooling asia.beast and staying in the base. Asia. beast was superivor and undefeated. Game is meaningless from the first minute.

I would think ehf's feeding as a way to complain. Apparently, game is no fun to both sides. And i also request a ban on Asia.beast.viewtopic.php?f=8&t=25305

[lolships]

You seem to be missing the point - asia.beast did not break any rules. The fact that you do not like something does not make it a bannable offense.
Someone getting upset and breaking the clearly stated rules listed at: viewtopic.php?f=5&t=4 (see "Ruining the game: ...feeding") IS a bannable offense.

As a side note - if you'd like to get the rules officially changed, you are welcome to attempt to do so! ENT is a pretty nifty community of players, and I'm sure people would be interested to hear your opinions and suggestions, listed as such

[mild7777seven]

You seem to be missing the point - asia.beast did not break any rules. The fact that you do not like something does not make it a bannable offense.
Someone getting upset and breaking the clearly stated rules listed at: viewtopic.php?f=5&t=4 (see "Ruining the game: ...feeding") IS a bannable offense.

As a side note - if you'd like to get the rules officially changed, you are welcome to attempt to do so! ENT is a pretty nifty community of players, and I'm sure people would be interested to hear your opinions and suggestions, listed as such

It is a bannable offense. Some 1 got banned for that. viewtopic.php?f=24&t=23708

[lolships]

There is some confusion about the issue of burning. The creators of the map have stated that it is an intended part of the mechanics, so any moderator who has issued a ban for it has done so incorrectly, albeit understandably as it's not an unreasonable assumption that burning is a glitch - it's just an incorrect assumption.

[mild7777seven]

There is some confusion about the issue of burning. The creators of the map have stated that it is an intended part of the mechanics, so any moderator who has issued a ban for it has done so incorrectly, albeit understandably as it's not an unreasonable assumption that burning is a glitch - it's just an incorrect assumption.

I agree that burning is ok. Actually, as a player, if the other side does not pool one guy so much like Asia.beast did, I am ok with that. However, in this case, no one except Asia.beast get fun. That is the reason I personally do not like it.
I suggest ban this guy. But again, that's only from my SUGGESTIONS. I am not admin, and lets just see what they gonna do.

[lolships]

Yeah, it will be interesting to see if everyone comes to an agreement on this. It seems kindof sketch to say that a strategy may or may not be okay depending on what the other team does, in a game-by-game basis. I think ideally people would be made more aware of the rules. maybe someone can update the loading screen or something? How do we force people to learn about something, when they're not the kind of people who want to do so on their own? Ultimately we come back to the eternal imbalance of wc3 players - the great divide among people who play for the sake of playing, and people who play for the sake of learning. Someone move this dialogue to the thread for aimless rambling.

[L1ghtniNG]

o

[L1ghtniNG]

If any of you want training, contact me on USEast server, L1ghtniNG, channel Clan BoaT

[JunZzi]

Right now, burning is not against the rules, I will deny this request.

You both used a glitch in the game, So call it fair game.

Moved to Processed.