[ID] Letbell@useast.battle.net

[Karmakas]

Your battle.net username: Karmakas
Violator's battle.net username: Letbell
Game name (if known): [ENT] Island Defense #70
Bot name (for example, ENT15): ENTID
Approximate date/time of game (alternatively, link to a Stats page): https://entgaming.net/findstats.php?id=3146493
Rule player violated: Feeding
Time of incidents (Note in-game timer or replay timer): At 12:00 Gold Penalty Timer
Any further thoughts: Top left of the map

[Stealer]

picture has a bit more of an exact time.

letbellfeed.PNG (2.38 MiB) Viewed 578 times

[Letbell]

(17:44 / Allied) Karmakas: I missed
(17:48 / Allied) Belthazar: why
(17:49 / Allied) Belthazar: are
(17:50 / All) ShadowWeaver: sat tk
(17:51 / Allied) Belthazar: you tking me
(17:52 / All) ShadowWeaver: Yellow tk
(17:54 / All) ShadowWeaver: gray tk
(18:03 / All) earthdart: U bk
(18:03 / All) ShadowWeaver: i report
(18:15 / Allied) Karmakas: blue I didn't kill anything
(18:18 / All) Letbell: o3o u want some feeds?
(18:21 / All) Letbell: :3 i can give u some
(18:22 / All) earthdart: Nope
(18:28 / Allied) Belthazar: i killed his hutner after he killed m stuff
(18:30 / All) earthdart: fine sure
(18:36 / All) Letbell: :3 alright
(18:39 / All) earthdart: MH
(18:39 / Allied) Karmakas: I didn't kill anyone's stuff
(18:43 / All) ShadowWeaver: titan i make feed
(19:12 / All) earthdart: i friendly
(19:19 / Allied) F_UCK_dis_game: goooollllllllldddddddddddddddddd
(19:22 / All) Letbell: Belthazar has left the game voluntarily.
(19:22 / QUIT) Belthazar: Left
(19:32 / All) Letbell: :3 ask me if u need more
(19:37 / Allied) Karmakas: why feed...
(19:47 / Allied) F_UCK_dis_game: cuz we can ?
(19:50 / Allied) Karmakas: no

O.o would you mind explain why not feed a titan level 4-5 in 20 minute game? I surely did offer him the feed, but apprently nobody bother wanted to reply to majortiy vote at this point right here. I doubt ShadowWeaver disagreed in this chat to attempt to feed titan too. Even F_UCK_dis_game support it.

Support: 2 agreed - 1 disagreed

Notice: No type of intentional game-ruining involve. Titan died through my tked base. Unless

[Karmakas]

It doesn't matter how many people "disagree", you need at least 60% of the living builders to agree to the feeding, and that wasn't the case. Our reasons for not agreeing with it are irrelevant.

[Letbell]

It doesn't matter how many people "disagree", you need at least 60% of the living builders to agree to the feeding, and that wasn't the case. Our reasons for not agreeing with it are irrelevant.

Ohhhh doesn't matter huh? Let me give you an example of what happen when 60% of votes doesn't work in your favor.

viewtopic.php?f=24&t=15859&p=75235#p75235

[Theon]
4 votes yes, 0 no = 100% yes
Feed = 2/1, Me, Vigilated- vs. Letbell. Only fed after Kevibear went down. Didn't want scghost to kill the rc's but he did anyway. I still needed for g2l

Would any moderator mind explaining this? I just remembered one of the old post that has this kind of situation and the initiators doesn't get banned for feeding titans on purpose too. Hmm... odd.

Hmm... Odd situation, this old post said these people feed titan and having fun and also said doesn't ruin game. In the end they doesn't get ban. Would that also applied to me as well? Hmm...odd.

[Karmakas]

aRt)Y does say that votes get voided, but that's in disagreement with the official rules. So I'm just gonna assume the rules changed in the meantime. And the current rules say you need "60% of the other players' consensus", it's as simple as that...

[Letbell]

aRt)Y does say that votes get voided, but that's in disagreement with the official rules. So I'm just gonna assume the rules changed in the meantime. And the current rules say you need "60% of the other players' consensus", it's as simple as that...

The rules was never changed, I've observed from time to time, it's still the same. The only things that changed is how the moderator judge it.

[Karmakas]

Well it's utterly ridiculous that unless the majority of players in the game specifically tell someone not to feed, that person is allowed to give the titan any feed they want...

[jew]

60% of players must vote. If there isn't a 60% majority among players, then it's not allowed.

Timmy is a bob.

Letbell banned 1 day as a warning, but in general do not do things that prolong the game unless a very clear majority agree to it--you can't say 1-0/2-0/3-0/2-1/3-1 etc. are a majority if not everyone votes and there are many more players in the game.