[viking_shield@east, lyteo23@west, abatoire@asia, metaxa@eu]

[Frank]

Your Warcraft III username: rehabs@west
Violator's Warcraft III username: my whole team (scourge)
Game name or map name: [ENT] DotA apem A-BAL us/ca #41
Approximate date/time of game (alternatively, link to a Stats page): http://clanent.net/openstats/game/1233716/
Rule player violated: I think its cool that ENT accepts new players who are willing to learn even if they're bad (we're all new at sometime) , but when they refuse to listen to you all game long i think it should be dealt with.
Time of incidents (Note in-game timer or replay timer): all game long its pretty evident: including constant afks from gyro /items stealings and blatant feeding from bh, poor item choices from sniper and ench, and etc... etc... (way to many specific times to matter youll notice them from minute 1)
Any further thoughts: prepare for a long fucking game, with a pen and paper because they all did something banworthy throughout the game despite my best efforts to give them advice (altho tbh i lost my cool a bit at the end...srry).

P.S. I encourage you to watch the whole replay because dis shit cray

[NutzSucksHard]

I encourage you to post ALL THE TIME marks. I will not watch one hour of this dota. No way. I bet you didn't too, cause you know the time right?

Take your own pen and paper, note the time, then come back. I use replay seeker every_single_ replay I watch. I need replay timer, otherwise, no look.

We're not paid, I'am not going to waste my spare time over a request that you didn't even re-looked at.

If you don't wanna do it, this request will just be denied in 24 hours.

Waiting for you.

[Frank]

Oh, i see. I thought i was doing the community a favor by reporting rule breakers. Thats fine i guess dont watch, and i dont think ill ever report again if this is the way the staff handles requests.

[Toshiro088]

I want to know, buying bad items, playing worst than others is now banneble... from what time? someone play better and someone cant do that well in game. Only one think is AFK, is banworthy so why you didnt suggest votekick? And second is Itemstealing and you can give a time for that easyly i think. its take for you only five minutes when you played that game.

But for playing bad i dont se why you want to ban that person. I would say you denny that, but i am not staff but i think there is somethink wrong when you want to ban player who do not play well.

See ya, Toshi.

[getstomped]

Oh, i see. I thought i was doing the community a favor by reporting rule breakers. Thats fine i guess dont watch, and i dont think ill ever report again if this is the way the staff handles requests.

He's not refusing to watch, hes saying that the moderators handle hundreds of requests a day. You want him to watch an hour long game? 100s of hours a day? Take 2 minutes of YOUR time since YOU'RE the one making the request, mark down a few times that prove YOUR point, and then he/another moderator will watch.

[NutzSucksHard]

Don't ever report again if it's what you want. Like getstomped said, it's not the only thing I've to do in my life right now, watching one hours for your own pleasure. You don't wanna bother with it cause you don't care much over your own request. That's all. If the requester doesn't care of it, why would we *staff* care. If you put some kind of effort, of heart inside the request, I would be more then happy to check it and having a look. But throwing a work to people that actually, keep the communities out of hacker, dealing with your crying, your appeal, the bot etc.

This is from you, a really nice thanks my dear friend. Hope you will enjoy your time on ENT

I still wait the 24 hours. Sometime people think differently, after a moment

[Bubblestorms]

Hmm.. I will take a look at this, I dislike people treating new players badly. Although next time, do try and note down the times when you think your team broke the rules or treated you with no respect. A new player playing at a standard, does not mean others should gang up on him, instead they should encourage him to do better. Checking this replay now.

[Frank]

This was the first ban request I ever made on ENT. Ok, I do understand that I have to put specific times but there was just so many and so frequently different incidents I (key word) THOUGHT its just worth looking over the whole thing.
If anything you don't have to watch the replay you just ban bh strictly from the fact that he has an item that doesnt belong to him in the gamestats page (snipers yasha recipe).

@NutzSucksHard : Keep on making assumptions about why I made the request... If i didn't care I wouldn't have posted now would I? A simple "You must provide specific times in-game" would have suficed. You can cut out all the "We're not paid blah blah blah my time is SO valuable" out of you post next time, im not trying to be aggresive but thats how you came across to me.
I still do appreciate that you're looking into it bubbles.

[NutzSucksHard]

Mine is valuable, like yours I bet. So don't come out telling stuff like this. You're new, I'am making you aware that we're doing this free. Look, I've dealt with over 300 request. If you don't fill them, I won't get a look for one hours of my time. I got stuff to deal In Real Life, you don't need to know these thing thought

Sorry for looking rude. Didn't meant to. But you're telling 'order' too :

prepare for a long fucking game, with a pen and paper because they all did something banworthy throughout the game

Frist, tell us what they did wrong? Maybe I will watch it and said, aww that's not an offense, but for you, this exact same situation, is the offense said. I need to see the replay in my neutral view, but also as your view. That's why I'am asking you to put time marks.

The rest wast to notify that we're doing this free and nicely for getting the communities better. You first came and looked like giving order to review it and it will be long. Yes, I don't mind of checking it, but I would prefer that you do it before me. It's like people coming and telling : Maphack, he just ganked all the time on me.

Ok.. So what? That's where I'am trying to bring you. Help us a bit in our work will just be appreciated. Seems like bubble have time to spend more then 1h on reviewing this. I will let him handle.

Again, nothing was mean to be rude. Just cause you're not the first, not the last

[EdgeOfChaos]

Reviewed:
Bounty Hunter steals Yasha recipe at around 50 minutes. 3 day ban.

No other offenses found. It seems to me that you just want to ban people who suck at the game. Also, you admitted to wanting to ban them for sucking here:

(57:29 / Allied) rehabs: ur banned
(57:31 / Allied) rehabs: for sucking

Therefore:
abatoire@europe.battle.net banned for 3 days
I saw some AFKing, but nothing I found excessive, no moving to prevent AFK (when he moved, he came back to game), and no AFKing during crucial moments (enemy team raxing)
No other bans

If I missed something (and there is another rule violation), private message me with times.

Please remember, sucking is not bannable. Bad item choice is also not bannable. And you were VERY disrespectful to your team, flaming the entire game, calling them noobs, etc, so it is no surprise they did not listen to you :\